Biomechanical Analysis of Knee Hyperextension and Impingement of the
ACL - Hans Passler
Purpose: To examine the interaction between the roof and the ACL
The population examined was ACL injury and hyperextension of the knee.
Cinematography was applied to the MRI to examine this relationship.
They found that with a steep tunnel angle and hyperextension, even when the tibial tunnel
was drilled posterior, there was graft impingement.
Conclusion: The patient with hperextension, and steep notch angle should be protected with
a brace that limits hyperextension for 3 weeks post-op.
Howell has also showed the relationship between the roof notch angle and the degree of
hyperextension.
Rehab should allow for full hyperextension
![]()
Structural Properties of Six Tibial Fixation Devices - Steve Howell
Fixation should be above 500N of load of activities of daily living.
Quads semi t was the graft tested.
He has developed a new fixation device that fits into the tibial tunnel and looks like a
spiked washer, called the washerplate.
Ultimate load Testing
Washerplate - 900N
RCI - 4 of 7 failed under 500N - slippage was significant
NO 5 sutures over post <500 N
Tunnel screw
Linvatec screw washer - only works with tandem screws
The fixation in humans is less than demonstrated in animals
How about adding the interference screw to the suture post. Probably significantly
increases the ultimate load.
The bone mulch increased stiffness, the same with the interference screw near the tunnel
exit.
The stiffness increases with the shorter fixation distance.
![]()
Comparison of Endoscopic vs Two Incision for ACL Reconstruction - Steve
Howell
This study showed that the endoscopic is the same as the 2 incision in 2 year follow up
![]()
Distal Fixation of ACL - Jurgen Eichhorn
The distal fixation is with a suture disc. Semi rigid fixation is preferable according to
Don Shelbourne. This is similar to the bioabsorbable 'cap' of Linvatec. The sutures are
then twisted to pull at 80n. The twisting increases the failure strength to 500N.
![]()
Improved Repeatability of ACL Reconstruction with Computer Assisted
Tunnel Localization - Burt Klos
This study looked at computer assisted fluoroscopic tunnel positions

Photo courtesy of Burt Klos
The template is placed over the lateral fluoroscopic x-ray to determine where the tunnel
should be.
In the discussion Don Shelbourne brought up that you should only switch your technique if
there is a problem. Change the technique to improve a problem, wait 2 years, then report
your results to show what you are doing is an improvement.
![]()
Guidelines for ACL Reconstruction in Children - Roger Larson
Age
Grafts - soft tissue do not fuse the plates- Arnoczky
No extra-articular repairs are recommended, they may interfer with the lateral aspect of
the growth plate.
Patellar tendon is also not recommended due to damage to the tibial tubercle.
Preferred treatment:
Semi-tendinosus graft
![]()
Prospective Review of ACL Reconstructions with Bioabsorbable Screw -
Phillip Neyret
MRI measurements on the tunnels were performed on ACL reconstruction with bioabsorbable
screws.
The femoral tunnel should be high in the notch.
There was relationship with a soft end point in follow-up and the tunnel placement.
The use of the bioabsorbable screws had no increase in complications.
![]()
Hydroxyapatite dowels for fixation of the ACL graft - Herman Mayr
The dowel is used to 'impact fixate' the patellar tendon bone plug, and this was compared
to the interference screw.
The pullout strength was less than the screw (50%)
![]()
Multiple Ligament Reconstruction - 2-5 year Follow-up - Chris Harner
This study reports on the results of operation for dislocated Knees -30 patients
17 spontaneous reduced - the rest had to be reduced in emergency.
Graft choice:
ACL- patellar tendon allograft
PCL - Achilles allograft
17 acute - within 3 weeks
6 vascular injuries - 3 complete - 3 intimal injuries
when in doubt, get an arteriogram
Also helpful is the ankle brachial ratio< .8 - get arteriogram
Intimal injury is a problem if operating within 24 hours
Summary: pulses normal, doppler normal, indices normal, - no arteriogram
ACL/PCL - medial
ACL/PCL - lateral
Rehab - brace in extension for 4-6 weeks
83% follow-up
IKDC - Subjective / ROM / Stability / overall
A - 9 7 3 0
B 13 13 14 10
C 3 4 8 8
D 0 1 0 7
Operation is generally successful, but return to sports and heavy work is variable
Often does a primary repair of the PCL
Allograft restores stability
MRI helps to evaluate the avulsion injuries and get early repair
EUA is extremely important to make decisions on the repair.
![]()
Postero-lateral Instability - Brian Casey
This was an overview of 15 years of observing the postero-lateral corner injury by Casey
Variable intra/extra fibrous response to surgery
Variable degree of ligamentous stability - hyperlax patients are more of a problem.
Variable anatomy of the posterolateral corner
Procedures
Patellar olecranization - may have a place
![]()
Treatment of Acute Lateral Ligament Injuries of the Knee - Thomas
Klootwyk - Shelbourne
Lateral side needs to be done within 3 weeks with open procedures.
Review the lateral anatomy 1,2,3, layers
Procedure - the injury is distal
Re-attach the lateral mass back to tibia - open
Results 17 patients
Most had ACL/PCL reconstruction
![]()
Instability and Arthritis - Osteotomy - G. Puddu
Combined ACL deficiency and medial compartment OA
Uses the open wedge osteotomy held with a plate, and no fibular osteotomy
Cuts the wedge with saw and osteotome, up to 1 cm of lateral side, then pry it open.
Bone graft the defect from the iliac crest
Post up - brace, WB partial 30 days and full at 45 days
![]()
Capsuloligamentous Injuries with Chondral injuries- Chrisitan Guier
These injuries were diagnosis with MRI scan - 8X increase in associated fractures in past
2 years
More injuries due to the parabolic skis and the internal rotation injury of Bob Johnson
The tibia will abut against the femur on reduction and cause a transchondral fracture of
the femur.
Common to have tibial plateau fractures
Operate for 2 mm of step off
![]()
Problems of Donor Site After ACL Reconstruction - Nic Piskopakis
This reviewed 1420 cases
This study divided the ACL reconstruction patients into 2 groups - with and without
aggressive rehab
The incidence of patellofemoral pain was 23%, this reduced to 4% with aggressive rehab
Patellar tendinitis was slightly more common in the aggressive rehab program
Muscle weakness same in both groups
Less loss of range of motion with aggressive rehab
The length of patellar tendon was longer in 8% and shorter in 6%
![]()
Non contact ACL Mechanism "The Position of No Return" Mary
Lloyd Ireland
This study determined that in 82% of ACL were non-contact mechanism.
There is a gender differences - 4X greater in females
She felt that position sense could be improved by training
She showed several basketball injuries that she called the "heart attack" of the
knee, and showed the position of no return.
This position of no return is:
Body forward flexed
Hip adducted
Internally rotated
Valgus flexion knee
Tibia externally rotated
Foot pronated
This is a distal deceleration with rotation
Prevention - training - emphasized by Erickson. (Proprioception and strength)
ACL is torn with valgus and rotation - Woo The main control of valgus is the ACL not the
MCL.
Off balance jump stop - brain has 'mini-stroke', the hamstrings forget to fire.
![]()
The Infuence of Menstrual Cycle on ACL Laxity - Rhidan Thomas
More ACL's during the menstrual cycle - old study from the 60's
Wojits found the highest ACL rate during the ovulatory phase ( more estrogen during this
phase)
Estrogne had inhibitory effect on fibroblasts of the ACL
Luteal phase had more a-p displacement measured by the KT-2000
There was no change with the oral contraceptive pill, is this a protective effect.
Conclusions: showed more ACL laxity with menstrual cycle
![]()
ACL Injury Rate of Men and Women at the United States Military Academy
- Dean Taylor
The injury rate is not different between men and women - 3.5% rate over 4 years
Reasons:
The injury rate at the Navy and Air Force have a higher rate in females,
but they play rugby at Navy. The numbers should be combined from all three academies
![]()
Distinct Patterns of Scans in Acute and Chronic ACL Deficient Knees -
Scott Dye
Daniel's studied the reconstructed knees with scans and showed a higher level of
degenerative changes compared to the non-operated knees. This may because they had more
menisectomies and some were 'tighter' due to casting post-op.
It is important to understand the concept of the 'load envelope'
1.Zone of homeostasis 2.zone of load acceptance 3.zone of overload
Bone bruise has a scan appearance that is different in the acute and chronic
Acute uptake is in the lateral - anterolateral femoral condyle and posterolateral tibia
Chronic injury uptake is in the medial -90% and only 10% in the lateral
![]()
Radiological Comparison of Graft Orientation in Endo vs 2 incision -
Gary Losse
The ACL graft position determines the success of the outcome of the operation
Is there a simple xray determination for graft position?
This was a complex measurement of x-rays that favoured his 2 incision technique. The
single incision technique was done by another surgeon. ( this weakens the study
conclusions)
Xray ap and lateral scanned and reference markers placed
There were differences in the one vs two incisions The endo was a shorter graft
Fuss ( Acta Anat 140:260-268, 1991) felt that the guiding bundle is the isometric bundle,
and this is placed in the optimum femoral position - posterior
Outcome: The endoscopic single incision had more laxity in follow-up. Losse does a
2 incision tech
Bone scans have been demonstrated as normal in both groups.
![]()